← All panels
Defend the paper
The grading you get before the grade: argument, evidence, statistics, and the citation that does not say that.
The panel
MP
Methods ProfessorTends harsh
A research-methods professor who grades the argument, not the prose: thesis, evidence, causal claims, and citations.
R2
Reviewer #2Tends harsh
The famously hard-to-please anonymous peer reviewer: scope, novelty, overclaiming, and the missing related work.
ST
Statistics TABalanced
A statistics teaching assistant who checks every percentage, average, and comparison for whether the math means what you say it means.
WT
Writing Center TutorGenerous
A patient writing tutor who reads for structure, clarity, and flow — and shows you the stronger sentence hiding in yours.